Michael Weatherly’s NCIS Return Faces a New Test in ‘Like and Subscribe’

Mark Harmon as Gibbs and Michael Weatherly as Tony DiNozzo during their NCIS: Origins reunion; this CBS still is from the Oct. 20 episode, not the Oct. 27 NCIS episode. — CBS

Summary

Michael Weatherly’s Tony DiNozzo is back in NCIS Season 24 as the agency’s director, in a season-long arc.
CBS’s Oct. 27 episode, ‘Like and Subscribe,’ gives the team a sailor’s murder tied to an online game show while teasing a distinct personal threat for Tony.
The network has not disclosed what Tony’s threat is, so the episode preview leaves the personal storyline open.
The hour is scheduled for 8 p.m. ET/PT on CBS, with streaming availability through Paramount+.

A different kind of problem for Tony

Michael Weatherly’s return to NCIS continues Tuesday with ‘Like and Subscribe,’ an episode that puts Tony DiNozzo’s off-duty life alongside the team’s murder investigation. CBS says the case begins when a sailor who competed on an online game show is found dead. The team discovers the killing was not about the show’s prize money. The same official synopsis promises that Tony will face ‘a threat far more intimidating than any killer,’ without identifying the source or nature of it.^[1]

That distinction gives the episode two separate hooks: the agents must look past the obvious financial angle in the sailor’s death, while Tony confronts something beyond a routine case. The available preview does not confirm whether the threat involves Tony’s family, his new position or another part of his life, so those possibilities remain open rather than established plot points.^{[1] [2]}

Weatherly’s return changes Tony’s place on the team

Tony is not returning as the wisecracking senior field agent viewers knew from his earlier years on the series. Paramount+’s official Season 24 guide says he came back to Washington to open a satellite office for his private security company, then took over as NCIS director after Leon Vance’s death and Gabriel LaRoche’s brief tenure. The guide describes Weatherly’s role this season as a season-long arc.^[3]

The change places him at the top of the agency he once worked for, making his encounters with former colleagues part of his new leadership job. TV Insider’s Oct. 27 look back at Weatherly’s exit and return notes that the ongoing Season 24 comeback follows his 2016 departure after Season 13, his return for a 2024 tribute episode, and the one-season Tony & Ziva spinoff. The current run is a larger commitment than a single guest appearance.^[4]

What viewers can expect tonight

CBS lists ‘Like and Subscribe’ as Season 24, Episode 4, written by Sydney Mitchel and Amy Rutberg and directed by Tawnia McKiernan. It is scheduled for 8–9 p.m. ET/PT Tuesday, Oct. 27, on CBS. Paramount+ Premium subscribers can stream the local CBS feed live; the network says the episode will be available on demand the next day for Essential subscribers.^{[1] [5]}

The setup makes Tony’s personal storyline the episode’s unresolved question, rather than simply another case-of-the-week detail. CBS has offered no further description of what he fears, and the preview does not say whether the challenge will alter his leadership or his relationships. For Weatherly’s first sustained NCIS return since leaving the series, the episode keeps the focus on how DiNozzo’s new authority fits with the personal life he built away from the agency.^{[1] [3]}

Reporting sources

This article follows our editorial standards. To report an error, see our corrections policy.